Why Is the Rwanda Plan Controversial?
Britain attempted something similar in 2022, when its Conservative government agreed to send asylum seekers to Rwanda to have their claims processed.
But the UK Supreme Court ruled the scheme unlawful in November 2023 because of the risk that people sent to Rwanda could subsequently be returned to countries where they faced persecution.
The policy was scrapped after Labour won the 2024 general election. Nobody was forcibly sent to Rwanda under the scheme.
The new European proposal differs because it targets migrants who have already exhausted their legal options to remain, rather than asylum seekers awaiting decisions.
Nevertheless, Human Rights Watch condemned the announcement Monday, citing Rwanda’s record of political repression and concerns about the treatment of deportees.
Judith Sunderland, a senior refugee and migrant rights official at the organization, said: "History has shown that third country transfers violate rights and cause suffering."
Rwanda was the scene of a genocide in 1994, when around 800,000 people, mostly ethnic Tutsis, were killed. President Paul Kagame’s forces ended the slaughter, but his government has since faced accusations of political repression, arbitrary detention and silencing critics.
The five governments say the arrangement will comply with international human rights law, while Rwanda insists it can offer migrants a chance to settle and work.
Whether the plan survives legal scrutiny remains to be seen. But the announcement shows that a deportation approach already being used by Trump is gaining support among European governments, despite the collapse of Britain’s earlier attempt.
Subscribe to view notification of our daily news
RwandaPodium © All Rights Reserved. Powered by nozatech.com